ASEAN NCAP (New Car Assessment Program for Southeast Asian Countries) has announced it is downgrading the safety rating of the new Proton X90 MC to a one-star rating. For context, when the X90 was first launched back in May 2023, it received a five-star rating.
According to ASEAN NCAP, the reason for the downgrade is the lack of essential advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) in the updated model. Previously, the X90 was offered with autonomous emergency braking, forward collision warning, lane departure warning, lane keep assist, rear cross traffic alert, blind spot monitoring and more.
However, the MC update stripped away all of that, with all three available variants not having any form of ADAS. This did not sit well with ASEAN NCAP, which said that under its 2021-2025 protocol, “a vehicle’s star rating is restricted if it performs poorly in any single category, ensuring all-round protection.”
“The removal of these technologies has caused the safety assist (SA) score to drop to a four-star level, while the motorcyclist safety (MS) category— which relies heavily on blind spot detection – has plummeted to a one-star rating. Consequently, the Proton X90’s overall rating is capped at one-star,” the assessment programme said in its release posted today.
The lack of ADAS (and other features) has resulted in a lower starting price by as much as RM30,000, with the X90 MC going for between RM99,800 and RM115,800 on-the-road without insurance. Under its visually unchanged exterior, there is a new turbocharged inline-four engine that replaces the previous three-cylinder unit with a 48-volt mild hybrid system.
The director general of the Malaysian Institute of Road Safety Research (MIROS), Siti Zaharah binti Ishak, commented, “We deeply regret Proton’s decision to remove life-saving ADAS technologies from the new facelift model. To protect consumers and maintain the integrity of safety standards, we have no choice but to revoke the 2023 five-star rating.”
“This serves as a reminder to all manufacturers: safety is not a trade-off. Do not sacrifice proven safety technology for face-value luxuries like infotainment systems or leather upholstery,” she added.
This is not the first time that Proton has downgraded safety features. It removed the side airbags from the Exora in 2017, and it was never offered again until the MPV was discontinued. We should also point out that unlike the pre-MC X90, Proton did not communicate anything about safety ratings in its marketing materials.
Proton X90
from RM106,800 
Proton S70
from RM59,800 
Proton eMas 7 PHEV
from RM109,800 
Proton X70
from RM106,800 
Proton Saga
from RM38,990 
Proton eMas 5
from RM59,800 
Proton X50
from RM89,800 
Proton eMas 7
from RM103,800 
prolever
on 
Sohai
on 
Hmmm
on 
Dah Menang Semua
on 
Richard Teo
on 
That Guy
on 
weewee
on 
Pau Chan
on 
commentors nob rain
on 
Haji Karim
on 
Firdaus
on 
Pohhytvu
on 
muhamad Mokhtar
on 
Dr Li on steriods painkiller
on 
Perokdua
on 
Lim Tat
on 
Kam
on 
ahhookpin
on 
LoneOpinion
on 
ilaff
on 
PiggaPeppa
on 
Johnson
on 
Contrarion
on 
contrarion
on 
contrarion nobra in
on 
Mimi
on 
Can oldies pls butt out
on 
Anil R
on 
Bumirepublik
on 
Bat
on 
Masakroti
on 
Meanwhile Saga, Bezza and Traz
on 
excellent driver
on 
Sturno
on 
Zuskopi
on 
Taman boy
on 
FinLur
on 
Hmmmmm
on 
AkooIm
on 
Eazy
on 
brake earlier 50m
on 
KY
on 
XYZ
on 
fair ncap?
on 
newme
on 
Syaiful Nizam Hassan
on 
Perlisian
on 
AI-generated Summary ✨
Comments emphasize that removing ADAS features from the Proton X90 downgrades its safety rating and overall safety, as ADAS benefits not only drivers but other road users like pedestrians and motorcyclists. Many feel that neglecting active safety features is a step backward, especially since ADAS can prevent accidents and save lives. Several argue that safety should be prioritized over cost and that the rating change reflects a shift toward heavier dependence on active safety technology.