Car Buyer's Guide
Advertisement

smart #5 Premium vs Brabus

smart #5 Premium

smart #5 Premium

smart #5 Brabus

smart #5 Brabus

Verdict

For most Malaysian buyers, the smart #5 Premium is the sensible call: it costs RM50,000 less, delivers a longer 590 km range and incurs RM455 annual road tax versus RM1,740. The Brabus answers with a serious 637 hp, 710 Nm and 3.8-second 0-100 km/h time, against 358 hp, 373 Nm and 6.5 seconds for the Premium. Both retain the same 100 kWh battery and 400 kW DC charging capability, so the extra money is chiefly for much stronger performance, all-wheel drive, 21-inch wheels and rear-seat upgrades.

Premium

Pick the smart #5 Premium if 590 km range, RM455 road tax and keeping RM50,000 in your pocket matter more than outright acceleration.

Brabus

Pick the smart #5 Brabus if its 637 hp dual-motor all-wheel-drive performance and more accommodating rear seating justify RM259,800.

Key differences

  • Price: smart #5 Premium RM209,800; smart #5 Brabus RM259,800.
  • Motors: smart #5 Premium one motor; smart #5 Brabus two motors.
  • Motor output: smart #5 Premium 358 hp and 373 Nm; smart #5 Brabus 637 hp and 710 Nm.
  • EV range: smart #5 Premium 590 km; smart #5 Brabus 540 km.
  • 0-100 km/h: smart #5 Premium 6.5 seconds; smart #5 Brabus 3.8 seconds.
  • Rear seats: smart #5 Premium 60:40 split-fold with sliding adjustment; smart #5 Brabus 60:40 split-fold with power reclining and Boss Switch.

Premium

  • RM50,000 less to buy.
  • 590 km range, 50 km more than the Brabus.
  • Lower RM455 annual road tax.
  • 358 hp and 373 Nm fall well short of the Brabus.
  • Rear-wheel drive rather than all-wheel drive.
  • No power rear-seat reclining or Boss Switch.

Brabus

  • 637 hp, 710 Nm and a 3.8-second 0-100 km/h time.
  • Dual-motor all-wheel drive.
  • Power-reclining rear seats with Boss Switch and sports suspension.
  • Costs RM50,000 more.
  • 540 km range is 50 km shorter.
  • RM1,740 annual road tax versus RM455.
Price & overview
PriceRM209,800✓RM259,800
Body typeSUVSUV
SegmentCompact ExecutiveCompact Executive
AssemblyCBUCBU
Ownership
Road tax / yearRM455✓RM1,740
Powertrain
Engine Tech800V architecture800V architecture
FuelElectricElectric
Number of Motors12
Motor Horsepower358 hp637 hp✓
Motor Torque373 Nm710 Nm✓
Battery Capacity100 kWh100 kWh
EV Range590 km✓540 km
Charging Rate (AC)22 kW22 kW
Charging Rate (DC)400 kW400 kW
V2L3.3 kW3.3 kW
Drivetrain
TransmissionSingle Ratio AutomaticSingle Ratio Automatic
DrivelineRear Wheel DriveAll Wheel Drive
Performance & Efficiency
0-100 km/h6.5 seconds3.8 seconds✓
Top Speed200 km/h210 km/h✓
Dimensions
Length4,705 mm4,705 mm
Width1,920 mm1,920 mm
Height1,705 mm1,705 mm
Wheelbase2,900 mm2,900 mm
Weight2,260 kg2,378 kg
Doors55
Seats55
Boot Space630 litres630 litres
Front Tyre255/45R20255/40R21
Rear Tyre255/45R20255/40R21
Factory TyresContinental EcoContact 7Continental EcoContact 7
Chassis
AssemblyChina (CBU)China (CBU)
Front SuspensionDouble WishbonesDouble Wishbones
Rear SuspensionMulti-linkMulti-link
Front Wheels20" Alloys21" Alloys
Rear Wheels20" Alloys21" Alloys
SteeringRack and Pinion (Electric Power Steering)Rack and Pinion (Electric Power Steering)
Chassis Notes—Sports Suspension
Safety
Airbags6 (Driver & Front Passenger, Side Airbags, Curtain Airbags)6 (Driver & Front Passenger, Side Airbags, Curtain Airbags)
ABS/EBD✓✓
Stability Control✓✓
Alarm✓✓
Immobilizer✓✓
Airbag Disable Function✓✓
Child Safety LockElectronic for Rear DoorsElectronic for Rear Doors
Seat Belts5 Three-point5 Three-point
Blind Spot Info System✓✓
ISOFIXAvailable On Front Passenger Seat, Rear Outer SeatsAvailable On Front Passenger Seat, Rear Outer Seats
Autonomous Braking SystemYes, Front and RearYes, Front and Rear
Lane-keeping AssistSteering CorrectionSteering Correction
Collision Warning✓✓
Seatbelt ReminderAll SeatsAll Seats
Lighting
HeadlampsLED Projectors with Auto High Beam & Auto LevellingLED Projectors with Auto High Beam & Auto Levelling
TaillampsFull LEDFull LED
LED Daytime Running Lights✓✓
Rear Foglamps✓✓
Wing Mirror Turn Indicators✓✓
Cabin
Front SeatsDriver and Passenger Powered SeatsDriver and Passenger Powered Seats
Rear Seats60:40 Split-fold with Sliding Adjustment60:40 Split-fold with Power Reclining and Boss Switch
Front Air-conDual-zone Automatic Climate ControlDual-zone Automatic Climate Control
Rear Air-conRear AC VentsRear AC Vents
SunroofPanoramic Glass RoofPanoramic Glass Roof
Power Sockets1 Front, 2 Wireless Chargers, 2 USB-C Front, 2 USB-C Rear1 Front, 2 Wireless Chargers, 2 USB-C Front, 2 USB-C Rear
Interior LightingMap Lights & Ambient LightingMap Lights & Ambient Lighting
Cup Holders2 Front, 2 Rear2 Front, 2 Rear
Sun ShadePowered Sunroof ShadePowered Sunroof Shade
Audio13" Twin AMOLED Touchscreens with Wireless Apple CarPlay & Android Auto, 20-speaker Sennheiser Sound System13" Twin AMOLED Touchscreens with Wireless Apple CarPlay & Android Auto, 20-speaker Sennheiser Sound System
Convenience
Power WindowsFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti PinchFour Windows, Auto Up and Down with Anti Pinch
Engine StartKeyless (Depress Brake Pedal)Keyless (Depress Brake Pedal)
LocksKeyless OperationKeyless Operation
Auto Headlamps✓✓
Auto Wipers✓✓
Cruise ControlAdaptive Cruise Control with Highway & Traffic Jam AssistAdaptive Cruise Control with Highway & Traffic Jam Assist
Steering Audio Control✓✓
Steering Tilt✓✓
Steering Telescopic✓✓
Boot OperationYes, Powered with Kick SensorYes, Powered with Kick Sensor
Parking Sensor Front6 Sensors6 Sensors
Parking Sensor Rear6 Sensors6 Sensors
Reverse CameraYes, With 360-degree CameraYes, With 360-degree Camera
Auto ParkingYesYes
Folding Wing Mirrors✓✓
Bluetooth✓✓
Navigation✓✓
Head-up Display✓✓
Hill Start Assist✓✓
Instrument ClusterFull LCD MonitorFull LCD Monitor
Parking BrakeElectronicElectronic
Warranty
Warranty Mileage ManufacturerUnlimitedUnlimited
Warranty Manufacturer4 years4 years
Warranty Notes8-year/200,000 km Battery Warranty & 8-year/150000 High Voltage Components Warranty8-year/200,000 km Battery Warranty & 8-year/150000 High Voltage Components Warranty

Specs shown for the selected variant of each car. ✓ marks the better figure where lower/higher is objectively better. Road tax: West Malaysia, private registration.

Premium vs Brabus FAQ

Is the smart #5 Premium or smart #5 Brabus better?

The Premium is the better buy for most people, with 590 km range and a RM50,000 lower price. Choose the Brabus only if 637 hp, all-wheel drive and 3.8-second acceleration are priorities.

What is the price difference?

The smart #5 Brabus costs RM50,000 more than the Premium: RM259,800 versus RM209,800.

Do the smart #5 Premium and Brabus charge at different speeds?

No. Both use a 100 kWh battery, support 22 kW AC charging and up to 400 kW DC charging, and provide 3.3 kW vehicle-to-load capability.

More comparisons

Buying one of these? Sell your old car, get paid in 24 hours

Related PaulTan.org Content: Motorsports | Tech | Featured: Featured | Malaysia: Malaysia | News: News | Reviews: Reviews